Project Due Diligence

Due Diligence for Safe U.S. Investment Immigration

For U.S. investment immigration EB-5, guaranteeing a U.S. green card or principal repayment is prohibited by law. Obtaining a green card and recovering the principal therefore depend entirely on the success of the immigration firm, the regional center, and the project the investor has chosen.
Because U.S. investment immigration involves the risk inherent in any investment, complex procedures, and legal acts by several related companies, investors need to fully understand the legal relationships involved and make careful choices. In particular, the areas investors should carefully investigate fall into three broad categories: the immigration firm, the regional center, and the project.

The immigration firm consults with the investor to assess their eligibility and, on the investor's behalf, conducts due diligence on the regional center and project, reviews and advises on immigration and investment law and the related documents, and supports related services from the green card application through principal recovery. For this reason, an immigration firm's “expertise” in immigration law and investment and its “trustworthiness” toward clients are critical factors in choosing one.

A regional center is a manager (company) approved by U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services (USCIS) for the purpose of U.S. economic development; it recruits investors, selects projects that qualify under investment immigration requirements, leads the raising of investment for them, and, on behalf of the investors (the investment company: NCE), manages the investment funds and makes major decisions for the investment company.

The project (developer), subject to the investment and job creation that are conditions for obtaining a green card, uses the investors' (company's) funds as equity (equity, preferred or common) or a loan (loan, bridge or mezzanine) to complete the project, then sells or refinances it and uses the resulting proceeds to return the investment (exit plan). The importance of the project in investment immigration can be described as absolute.
This is because the investor's green card, the removal of conditions, and principal repayment all depend on whether the project succeeds

The Importance of Project Selection

In U.S. investment immigration EB-5, project selection comes first in importance.
From the investor's perspective, the U.S. investment immigration program has two goals: obtaining a green card and repayment of the investment. Obtaining the conditional green card, obtaining the permanent green card, and principal repayment of the investment are directly tied to whether the project succeeds

Let us look at an example of how investment funds are used and repaid;
The project company borrows investment funds from EB-5 investors and uses them to build the project. In the process it creates jobs, enabling the investors to receive green cards, and once the project is successfully completed, it repays the investors from the proceeds.
If the project fails, however, and does not create jobs or generate revenue, the investors will neither obtain green cards nor receive principal repayment. This is U.S. investment immigration law.

Because investors must make an investment that bears the risk required by immigration law, the key is to have the principal repaid as safely as possible, and investors must understand where the funds are actually invested and whether the party using the funds is able to repay them safely.
For these reasons, project selection is extremely important in U.S. investment immigration.

Permanent green card information image

Permanent Green Card

A U.S. green card gives its holder the right to live and work in the United States and is commonly known as a "green card." Permanent green card holders can freely live and work in the United States and enjoy nearly the same protections as citizens, except for the right to vote. Permanent green card holders can also study or start a business in the United States and apply for citizenship through legal procedures.

To obtain a permanent green card through the U.S. investment immigration program, the investor invests at least $800,000 and, when that investment creates 10 or more jobs, the investor and accompanying family members obtain green cards. The green card obtained at this stage is called a conditional green card because a green card obtained through investment immigration is valid for two years, and within that period the investor must prove that 10 or more jobs have been created by filing a petition to remove conditions (I-829 Petition). Once this petition to remove conditions is approved, the investor receives a permanent green card. A permanent green card can be renewed every 10 years indefinitely.

Principal Repayment

In investment immigration, principal repayment means the investor receiving back the amount invested: after the investment company (NCE) receives back the funds it invested in or lent to the borrower company (the project company or developer), the investor receives back the funds they invested. An investor may apply for a permanent green card two years after obtaining a conditional green card through investment immigration.

Investment immigration law provides that the investment must remain invested for at least two years after the conditional green card is obtained in order to receive a permanent green card. In investment immigration, this is called the minimum investment period (Sustainment of Investment). In other words, if the principal is repaid within the minimum investment period, a permanent green card cannot be obtained, so the principal must be repaid only after the investment period has passed; moreover, when the invested or lent investment immigration funds are recovered, the principal can be repaid on the later of two dates—for example, the date of repayment from the developer or project company and the date two years after the conditional green card was obtained.

In investment immigration, principal repayment depends entirely on the success of the project the investor has chosen.
This is because the project company borrows the investors' funds, uses them to build the project, successfully completes the project, and repays your investment from the proceeds.

Project Due Diligence

Project due diligence refers to the key matters that investors must check about a project before deciding on it.
Since the purpose of investment immigration is to obtain a green card and principal repayment, please be sure to check the following.

1. Commercial Viability of the Project

· Check whether the business plan (the blueprint of the business) meets the Matter of Ho standard (market research, revenue projections, marketing strategy, etc.)
· Analyze whether the business has a realistic structure that can actually operate

2. Capital Structure and EB-5 Fund Use Plan

· Overall financing structure (EB-5 vs. equity capital, loans, etc.)
· Whether it is clear where the EB-5 funds will be used (costs related to direct job creation)

3. Job Creation Plan

· Whether at least 10 direct or indirect jobs are created per investor
· Whether economic models such as RIMS II or IMPLAN are used

4. Developer and Sponsor Track Record

· Past successes and failures of EB-5 projects
· The same developer's USCIS approval rates and repayment record

5. Reliability and Track Record of the Regional Center

· The Regional Center's approval status and any history of warnings or sanctions
· Past I-526 and I-829 approval rates

6. Safeguards and Collateral Structure (Security of Investment)

· Whether collateral is provided: real estate collateral, UCC-1, equity pledges, etc.
· Investor priority (Senior, Mezzanine, Equity, etc.)

7. Interest and Repayment Terms

· Interest payment method (paid vs. accrued)
· Maturity date, early repayment options, repayment priority

8. Immigration Risk Analysis

· Likelihood of I-526E and I-829 approval
· Conditions and timeline for maintaining/removing the conditional green card, and whether job creation will be achieved within that period

9. Redeployment Plan

· Plan for redeploying the investment in the event of early repayment
· The scope of redeployment permitted since the RIA and the NCE's Redeployment strategy

10. Contract Review and Investor Rights/Obligations (Details)

· PPM, Subscription Agreement, Operating Agreement, Loan Agreements, etc.
· Rights and obligations of investors/operators

Project due diligence good-to-know information image

Good to Know

The business plan describes the project as a whole, so it is a great help in understanding the entire project. The business plan is the plan for the project itself, and you should check how realistic and credible it is. As held in Matter of Ho, a business plan must be comprehensive, specific, and realistic, and objectively credible. The decision stated that an investment immigration business plan must include the following.

10 Essential Elements of a Business Plan (Matter of Ho Standard)

In its decision in Matter of Ho (22 I&N Dec. 206, AAO 1998), U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services (USCIS) held that the business plan attached to an EB-5 petition (Form I-526/I-526E) is recognized as “comprehensive and credible” only if it meets the following requirements.

“For a business plan to be comprehensive and credible, simple or vague statements are not enough; it must include a specific and feasible explanation of job creation and financial viability.”

The investor bears the burden of proving that the business plan is realistic, specific, and consistent with EB-5 regulations.

1Business Overview

· Description of the nature and purpose of the business
· The products or services offered

2Market Analysis

· Definition of the target market
· Analysis of the competitive landscape
· Market entry and marketing strategy

3Staffing Plan

· Organizational chart and personnel structure
· Positions to be filled and their roles
· Hiring timeline and phased recruitment plan

4Direct Job Creation Plan

· Plan to create 10 full-time jobs per investor
· Specific job duties and hiring dates

5Use of Funds Plan

· Specific uses of funds, including the EB-5 investment
· Fund disbursement schedule

6Financial Projections

· Income statements, cash flow statements, and balance sheets for at least the next five years
· Stated assumptions underlying the financial projections

7Business Timeline

· Milestones of major business activities
· Planned start and completion dates for each phase

8Corporate and Ownership Structure

· Type of entity (LLC, LP, etc.)
· Equity structure of investors and stakeholders

9Business Timeline

· Licenses, permits, and registration requirements needed to conduct the business
· Supporting documents showing whether they have been applied for or obtained

10Corporate and Ownership Structure

· Evidence supporting the feasibility of the business
· May include third-party feasibility reviews or expert opinions